BMW ECU programming tool performance comparison, which one to choose?


Topic: which tool support basic diagnosis and ECU programming for BMW? Have one blank ECU, and want to program it.

 

Obdexpress.co.uk engineer provided the suggestions:

If you only want to read and write ECU, Kess V2, KTAG, CG FC200, VVDI2 are good choices. But they cannot diagnose.

If you are doing ECU programming and diagnosis, recommend to use VXDIAG and Autel tablet.

Program BMW ECU online depending on the car model supported.

 

Kess V2:

BMW ECU programming tool

Price: €87

Highlights:

  1. Online Version Kess V2 Firmware V5.017 support online service by internet connection
  2. 100% No Tokens Need for all vehicles, no tokens reset button, you can use Kess V5.017 for lifetime
  3. Cover all major brands and protocols including Line, KAN, EDC17 and MED17 and for Ford J1850.
  4. Support cars/ trucks/ tractors/ bikes. KESS V2 supports vehicles according to the engine, so KESS V2 can support new vehicles!
  5. Read and write ECU via OBD2 port directly, no need to disassemble ECU from the car, easy to use.
  6. Support Multi-language:English, German, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, French.
  7. Support Multi-system: Win XP / Win7 32bit, Win 8, etc.

 

KESS 5.017 / KTAG 7.020 support models list
KESS V2.80 Version Software download Link
Password: v93vhe

 

KTAG V7.020:

BMW ECU programming tool

Price: €82

Highlights:

  1. It supports Online Version operation, can connect to the internet when installing & running the software. No worry lock anymore.
  2. Real no tokens limited anymore, Unlimited Token.
  3. It can do all functions of KTM100 KTAG 7.003.
  4. Supports more protocols, added 140 more ECU types Than KTAG 6.070.
  5. KTAG 7.020 supports more cars till 2016
  6. Add ECU Type: Toyota 76FXXX, PSA 17.4.4, Ford E83, VW 17.5.5 (1766), Mercedes-Benz 276ECU,Toyota 76F ECT..at least 100 more ECU Types added.
  7. Works Very Well On DENSO, GPT, NEC Protocols.
  8. Add New File type (FENDT/JCB/VALTRA TRACTOR BOSCH EDC17CV41 SISU ENGINE CAN)
  9. KTAG 7.020 add new color GPT Cable for GPT Function
  10. KTAG v7.020 can easily read and decrypt the secret password and it automatically unlocks/unprotects the Tricore sectors so it can read and write both Flash and Eeprom
  11. Support Languages: Italian, Deutsch, English, French, Portuguese, Spanish
  12. Support Systems: Windows XP / Win7/ Win8

Kess 5.017 Ktag 7.020 support models list

 

CG FC200 ECU Programmer:

BMW ECU programming tool

Price: €629

Highlights:

  1. Auto ECU Programmer for repair necessary-Support BMW ECU Data reading, writing, and clone.
    Effectively solve the problem of replacing the second-hand computer after the damage of BMW ECU control unit, just need to read the original computer data and then clone it.
    Support almost all the BMW ECU models for reading and writing: MSV90/ MSD85 MSD87 N20 N55 B48 B58 etc.
    Successfully make up the market for BMW ECU reading and writing equipment, save you high equipment costs.
  2. Auto Locksmith necessary-Support BMW IMMO functions, Read BMW ISN Code by OBD
    Quickly solve the problem for data collection of BMW all key lost.
    With more stable and efficient unremovable functions
    If you want to do all key lost for BMW 3 Series 5 Series 7 Series X5 X6 GT535 Six-cylinder engine, must need ISN code to program the keys.
  3. Original from CGDI and Free Update Online for One Year (After one year, it will cost $125/year)
  4. FC200 not only supports BMW ECU but also supports over three thousand ECUs like KTAG, Kess, Kessy, Dimsport, etc.
  5. Bosch search: Free to find out what ECU type
  6. With CAN-bus, No Disassembly (platform mode), and Boot mode
  7. Multi-Language: English, French, Spanish, Polish, Traditional Chinese, and Simplified Chinese
  8. Full Version with All License Activated and Free.

Download the latest software V1.0.4.1 of CG FC200

FC200 Support ECU list

 

Xhorse VVDI2:

BMW ECU programming tool

Price: €1,274

Highlights:

  1. VVDI2 full authorization comes with Basic Function + VW + BMW + Porsche+ AUDI Generation 5 function + BMW OBD Function + BMW CAS4+ BMW FEM+ ID48 96bit+ ID48 OBDII+ MQB Key Learn+ Toyota H Chip Authorization All 13 software activated. No Need to buy other Authorization.
  2. Support VW, Audi, BMW and Porsche, PSA (PSA Software only support key learn and read pin code)
  3. Update Online Free Lifetime, Latest version: V7.2.0
    Xhorse VVDI2 V7.2.0 Software Download link

 

VXDIAG VCX SE for BMW

BMW ECU programming tool

Price: €201

Highlights:

  1. Supports BMW All Series Diagnose and Programming.
  2. Supports Vehicles including for BMW Cars, Rolls- Royce, and Mini Cooper.
  3. Supports BMW from 2004 to 2021.
  4. Supports Wifi & USB connection, with Type-C USB connection, faster communication.
  5. This version comes with 500GB Software HDD, pre-installed, directly to use.

 

Supported Car List:
BMW 1 Series (E81, E82, E87, E88, F20, F21, F52, F40)
BMW 2 Series (F22, F45, F46)
BMW 3 Series (E46, E90, E91, E92, E93, F30, F31, F34, G20)
BMW 4 Series (F32, F33, F36)
BMW 5 Series (E60, E61, F10, F11, F07, F18, G30, G31, G38)
BMW 6 Series (E63, E64, F06, F12, F13, G32)
BMW 7 Series (E65, F01, F02, F03, F04, G11, G12
BMW X1 (E84, F48)
BMW X2 (F39)
BMW X3 (E83, F25, G01)
BMW X4 (F26, G02)
BMW X5 (E53, E70, F15, G05)
BMW X6 (E71, E72, F16)
BMW X7 (G07)
BMW I3
BMW I8
Mini (R50, R52, R53, R55, R56, R57, R57, R58, R59, R60, R61, F54, F55, F56, F60)

 

Autel diagnostic tool recommended: Autel MS908P Pro, Autel MK908P, Autel Ultra

  Product name Autel MS908P Pro Autel MK908P Autel Ultra Note
  IMG BMW ECU programming tool BMW ECU programming tool BMW ECU programming tool  
  Price €2,285 €2,017 €4,128  
Hardware configuration Release Date 2018 2019 2020  
CPU Exynox 5260 Exynox 5260 Exynos8895  
RAM 2G 2G 4G  
ROM 64G 64G 256G  
battery capacity 11000mAh 15000mAh 18000mAh  
Android version Android 4.4.2 Android 4.4.2 Android 7.0  
Screen size 9.7inch 10.1inch 12.9inch  
Screen resolution 1024x768 1920x1200 2732x2048  
Wi-Fi 2.4 & 5 GHz 2.4 & 5 GHz 2.4 & 5 GHz  
camera Rear 8.0 Megapixel Rear 8.0 Megapixel Rear 16.0 Megapixel,  
Front 5.0 Megapixel
Weight 1.53 1.53 2.2  
VCI Maxiflash Elite Maxiflash Elite MaxiFlash VCM All VCIS can be connected to VCI and tablet via USB cable, Maxiflash VCI/VCMI adds WiFi connection
Main functions basic function (read/clear code, data stream)  
Service  
Special function  
Action test  
Programming Benz programming online  
BMW programming online  
Ford programming offline  
Mazda programming offline  
Jaguar programming offline  
Vaxhall programming offline  
Opel programming offline  
Coding online Benz coding online (SCN)  
BMW coding online  
Audi coding online  
Porsche coding online  
VW coding online  
Nissan coding online  
Nissan-GTR coding online  
Infiniti coding online  
Hyundai coding online  
 iDrive BMW iDrive √ (Need to buy extra OTG conversion cable and F chassis professional harness) √(Need to buy extra OTG conversion cable and F chassis professional harness) BMW coding does not need to differentiate chassis, but BMW E chassis uses CAN/KWP protocol to set the code, and BMW F/ G/I chassis uses TCP protocol to set the code
VW、Audi、Skoda iDrive  
VW、Audi、Skoda, Seat、Bently, Man LD guiding function  
Guiding function McLaren, Tesla diagnostic functions X  
Other functions Auto VIN  
SCAN VIN/License X X  
Remote Desk  
Extended function Oscilloscope(works with MP408) included in VCMI VCMI comes with oscilloscope, signal generator, multimeter, signal check 4 major functions
Endoscope(works with MV105/MV108)  
ADAS expand X  
Battery test X  
Remote expert X  
Feature Smart diagnosis(TSB technical bulletin, fault code guidance, fault priority sorting, maintenance video, etc  ) X X  
Diagnosis system topological graph X X  
Standard of Diagnosis D-PDU/RP1210 X X  
Bus protocol DoIP/CAN FD X X If VCI does not support CAN FD,  add a CAN FD connector
  Language English English, Chinese, Spanish, French, German, Polish, Italian, Japanese, Korean, Dutch, Portuguese, Swedish, Russian English  

So, which is the best one? It just depends on what function you want to do and your budget. Hope this post helps you!

 

Thanks to www.obdexpress.co.uk for the information in writing this article.